Who would u rather have in ur side? U will probz def say buddy, but if u break it down id prefer cloke. Marking- cloke FA- buddy gives away too many free kicks Goals-buddy by a small margin Accuracy- haha tuffy. EVEN! Clokey is hard to beat on his day. Forget 2012 that was his crap year and he still got 50+ goals. Clokes also younger. I'd take cloke. A bit biasedWho would u rather have in ur side? U will probz def say buddy, but if u break it down id prefer cloke. Marking- cloke FA- buddy gives away too many free kicks Goals-buddy by a small margin Accuracy- haha tuffy. EVEN! Clokey is hard to beat on his day. Forget 2012 that was his crap year and he still got 50+ goals. Clokes also younger. I'd take cloke. A bit biased

Buddy is an absolute freak of nature, Cloke couldn't be used with any real effect in the midfield, the size and speed of buddy make him near impossible to match up on.

I doubt Cloke has the potential to even go close to 100 goals in a season, never mind breaking it. And scoring is the main thing I'd look for from a big forward. I have the last few years. I'd say 75 is about his cap. If he gets much more than that I'll readily admit to being wrong, but I doubt it will happen.

Agreed with Stomper on that one. I myself will also take Buddy over Cloke anyday and very comfortably.

Sorry Mate, but I'd take Buddy anyday over Cloke, Cloke can not match what Buddy does on the ground and in general play, can you imagine Cloke kicking those running, bouncing goals from the boundary that Buddy kicks. Buddy can kick 100 in a season, I really don't think Clokey will ever do that.