Well it's a topic that will be argued forever. Gary Ablett Jr probably is the best overall but Leigh Matthews was a beast back in his day. The difference in the way the game is played pretty much ruins the chance of ever knowing.
I'm pretty young so I haven't seen a lot of the old legends play but in my time I would have to say Gary Ablett jr. Sometimes when he plays he just makes everyone else look like they are in slow motion...
Robert dipper er dipperma er the bloke with the big chocco name! Cheers.
Wayne "the lunch cutter" Carey and possibly Gazza Jr after a few more years!
JOE NAMATH