Franklin has a lot of talent, but I think given his inconsistency and inaccuracy in front of goal, he shouldn't be considered the best key forward. For me, J. Riewoldt, T. Walker (on last year's form), T. Cloke and J. Kennedy could all be ahead of Franklin. Buddy's great on the highlights, not so great on consistence. I wouldn't want to be a team that relies on him (which fortunately for Hawks fans, they don't). What do you think? Which key forward would you most want on your team, if you had only one?Franklin has a lot of talent, but I think given his inconsistency and inaccuracy in front of goal, he shouldn't be considered the best key forward. For me, J. Riewoldt, T. Walker (on last year's form), T. Cloke and J. Kennedy could all be ahead of Franklin. Buddy's great on the highlights, not so great on consistence. I wouldn't want to be a team that relies on him (which fortunately for Hawks fans, they don't). What do you think? Which key forward would you most want on your team, if you had only one?

St Nick for mine, Cloke Buddy and Jack all good but tend to go missing

Josh Kennedy and Jack Riewoldt, add Nick Riewoldt in there to. Franklin's lost form, hasn't been scoring high at DT at all for Weeks.

The pav

If you're going to say Buddy is inconsistent then you have to say Jack Riewoldt is as well. Also up there are Jarryd Roughead and Jeremy Cameron.